The
science of Duck Call Sound
There is a scientific study being done at
this time, to determine what takes place inside a duck call.
We should learn how the sound is produced and possibly information
that will contribute to how to improve duck call sounds.
This study came about because several Call
Makers came together in a small private forum to share call
making ideas and methods.
At the time the study Data becomes available,
I will be posting an addition to this page with what we
have learned from this study.
Doc Calls No-Stick
Design
Duck calls have been affected by the “sticking”
problems for as long as I can remember. Some calls are subject
to sticking more than others and there are now several calls
that claim to be stick resistant or stick proof.
We know that all calls will fail to operate
if the temperature is low enough to cause actual freezing
of the call.
We also know that impediments (weeds, food
particles, etc.) that get into the call and can block the
reed from oscillating and will cause calls to fail to operate.
Most of the modern calls are made with very
little space between the edges of the insert and the interior
wall of the call barrel. A few call makers use the Glodo
style of barrel that provides a larger internal space in
the barrel and therefore more space for moisture to get
away from the surface of the insert and reed.
The “Sticking” problem we are
discussing here is caused by the collection and retention
of moisture, under and around the reed and sound surface
of the insert in the duck call. This moisture is a combination
of saliva from the operator’s mouth and condensation
moisture which collects inside the call barrel, due to the
temperature differential between the air introduced into
the call and the surface temperature of the call parts.
The idea that “all men are created
equal” sounds good for some things, but it is not
true as to some physical qualities for many of us. My many
years as a Dentist gives me an insight as to how much individuals
will vary as to the production of saliva and the very different
quality of saliva from one person to another. This leads
us to understand why some call operators will not be able
to blow dry air or limit how much moisture they put into
a call. Therefore the advice to blow dry or hot air just
won’t help people who have little or no control over
the amount of saliva they generate while blowing a duck
call.
Now that we have an understanding that moisture
is always going to be a problem for many duck hunters and
call operators, I need to provide a call that will continue
to operate functionally, even in a high moisture situation.
I don’t think many hunters would use a shotgun that
would regularly fail to operate during a hunt and those
same hunters should not tolerate a failure of their call
during the hunt.
Surface tension between the moisture on
the sound surface and the reed is the primary cause of the
sticking problem. Therefore if the surface area is reduced,
so is the surface tension reduced. Two ways to reduce surface
area is to make the reed smaller or the sound surface smaller.
I have explored both methods mentioned and both work well
enough to be useful in limiting a call sticking problem.
There are other ways to limit surface tension
including the use of Rain-X and lip balm but these are only
very short term fixes and of questionable effectiveness.
I did the first work in my attempt to fix
this problem in about 1996 by cutting down the width of
the reed and used this method for a couple of years. Sometime
during this period I came up with the idea to try cutting
down the surface of the insert.
The first generation of stick resistant
inserts, the cutout modification, was short and close to
the wedge cork. This worked fairly well but some sticking
persisted for some callers. After a time I increased the
length of the cutouts and the sticking was effectively eliminated
for most if not all users. At the time of making this change
I noticed a distinct improvement in the low end “Duck”
in every insert that was modified this way. The latest change
in the design occurred when I shared this information with
a small private forum made up of a few very good duck call
makers who came to the same general conclusion regarding
the effectiveness of the design and improvement of the sound.
|